The United States and Russia are expected to resist efforts to begin negotiations on legally binding international rules governing autonomous weapons at a United Nations meeting in Geneva this week, despite growing support from most countries for tighter controls.
The meeting, which opened on Monday, is considering whether to launch negotiations on a legal agreement covering prohibitions and restrictions on Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems (LAWS).
Advances in artificial intelligence have accelerated the development of military equipment, including drones, robots, tanks and submarines, capable of identifying and attacking targets with little or no human involvement.
Although the technology raises serious ethical and legal concerns, semi-autonomous and AI-assisted weapons have already been deployed in conflicts in Ukraine, Sudan and the Middle East.
Most of the 128 countries party to the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons support negotiations towards a binding agreement. However, major military powers, including the US, Russia and Israel, oppose the initiative, maintaining that existing international humanitarian law is adequate to regulate the use of such weapons.
In a video message to delegates, UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres called on countries to agree to begin work towards a legally binding instrument that would establish clear prohibitions and restrictions.
He warned that advances in autonomous weapons were creating new humanitarian, legal, ethical and security challenges as the nature of warfare continued to change.
Russia, however, delayed proceedings on Monday by objecting to a procedural arrangement that would allow observers, including representatives of the European Union and non-governmental organizations, to address the meeting.
Ireland, Canada and other delegates opposed Russia’s objection.
The International Committee of the Red Cross and the Pope have also raised concerns about the dangers associated with weapons that can operate without direct human control.
Rights groups warn of growing threat
Human Rights Watch has urged delegates to take decisive action, warning that allowing machines to determine who is targeted and killed on a battlefield could have serious consequences.
Verity Coyle of the organization described the prospect as a dystopian reality that was approaching rapidly, arguing that decisions over life and death should never be left to machines.
Campaigners say autonomous weapons could behave unpredictably, increasing the likelihood of errors that result in civilian deaths or other unintended casualties.
Anna Hehir, head of military AI governance at the Future of Life Institute, a US-based non-profit focused on reducing risks associated with advanced technologies, said lethal autonomous weapons were no longer merely theoretical.
She pointed to media reports of the early use of fully autonomous systems in Ukraine as evidence that the technology was already entering modern warfare.
The US supports the development of guidelines rather than legally binding restrictions, arguing that existing international law already provides a framework for regulating armed conflict.
Washington has proposed a five-year mandate for discussions aimed at producing a non-binding agreement.
Hehir said the US and Russia were likely to push for weaker language in any final agreement, similar to their position during negotiations in September on a text addressing autonomous weapons and the potential harm they could cause.
Compromise remains possible
Despite the divisions, diplomats said there was still a possibility of reaching an agreement before the meeting ends later this week.
Two diplomats told Reuters that negotiations would be difficult but that delegates could settle on a compromise. Options under consideration include a legally binding treaty, a non-binding agreement or a hybrid arrangement combining elements of both.
The chair of this week’s meeting has proposed a two-year mandate to negotiate a legally binding protocol.
The outcome will determine whether countries move towards formal international restrictions on autonomous weapons or continue discussions under a less binding framework.

























































































