Efforts to establish a framework for negotiating a legally binding international treaty on autonomous weapons have failed after a week of discussions at the United Nations ended without consensus, following Russia’s prolonged objections.
Negotiations at the UN Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons (CCW) conference in Geneva broke down shortly before 5am after overnight talks failed to resolve disagreements over how to regulate artificial intelligence-powered weapons.
Despite broad support among participating countries for a legally binding agreement, the convention’s consensus-based decision-making system forced delegates to settle for a weaker proposal calling for countries to continue developing an instrument through consensus, without guaranteeing legally enforceable obligations.
Russia was accused of obstructing progress through prolonged delays, while the United States and several other military powers also resisted committing to binding restrictions on autonomous weapons technology.
More than 100 countries had advocated introducing new international rules, arguing that AI-powered weapons present challenges that existing humanitarian law cannot adequately address. Several European and NATO countries, alongside Ukraine, China and Iran, expressed support for negotiations towards a new protocol.
However, the US and other countries with significant investments in military artificial intelligence were reluctant to accept binding commitments. Washington argued that existing international humanitarian law could provide a sufficient framework for addressing the risks.
The United States also pointed to discussions on maintaining human control over autonomous weapons during meetings between President Donald Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping at the APEC summit, but did not commit to a legally binding agreement.
South Korea, Japan, Turkey, Britain, France and Germany were among the countries exploring AI-assisted military technologies that opposed being subjected to new binding rules, instead favouring a non-binding arrangement.
Consensus rules hinder progress
The CCW operates through consensus, requiring all 128 member states to agree before adopting decisions. The system has made it difficult to introduce new international restrictions on weapons, with the forum failing to establish major new arms-control laws in the past three decades.
The deadlock has prompted countries seeking stronger restrictions to pursue agreements through alternative diplomatic platforms, as happened with the 2008 treaty banning cluster munitions.
Max Tegmark, chair of the Future of Life Institute, criticized the outcome, arguing that autonomous weapons were already being deployed while governments continued debating international safeguards without making meaningful progress.
Campaigners also staged public demonstrations in Britain, including a billboard campaign near Parliament calling for an international treaty and urging the government to ensure humans retain control over weapons systems.
Diplomats involved in the Geneva discussions accused Russia of deliberately prolonging proceedings and obstructing negotiations. They said US representatives, by contrast, had attempted to find a compromise that could secure a consensus statement, although Washington remained opposed to binding restrictions.
The final day was also marked by tension over the exclusion of several countries that are not members of the convention from the negotiations. Egypt’s delegation protested the decision during proceedings, with representatives shouting at the conference chair.
Concerns over AI-assisted military targeting
The failure to reach an agreement comes amid growing concerns about the use of artificial intelligence in military operations, particularly in Gaza and Iran, where Israel and the United States have deployed AI-enabled targeting systems.
The systems have been linked to extensive military strikes and large numbers of casualties. The Pentagon reportedly struck more than 1,000 targets in Iran on the first day of the war, while investigative reports have indicated that the US military is seeking to increase its capacity to make as many as 1,000 AI-assisted targeting decisions per hour.
Critics of the negotiations’ outcome said countries had squandered an opportunity to establish safeguards after more than a decade of discussions on the risks posed by lethal autonomous weapons. They argued that significant portions of a potential treaty had already been developed during previous negotiations.
A European diplomat said the failure reflected a lack of political commitment to match the urgency of regulating the technology.
Bonnie Docherty, a senior arms adviser at Human Rights Watch who has participated in efforts to secure previous international weapons treaties, argued that autonomous weapons required legally binding restrictions. She said a treaty could be negotiated within 15 months and criticized the US proposal for a five-year period to establish a negotiating mandate as unnecessarily slow.
Austria, Belgium, Brazil, Ireland, Mexico, New Zealand and Panama had jointly pushed for negotiations on a binding treaty to begin within a year.
Brazil also warned during the conference that lethal autonomous weapons were already being used and developed, arguing that international efforts to establish rules governing their deployment had fallen behind the technology.



























































































